AI ML
Post #7318 · source on Telegram
LLMs Lack World Knowledge but Have PhD-Level Intelligence: Both Sides Right
Description
A screenshot of a post by Paul Musgrave (dated 16 Jul) on what appears to be Substack or a similar platform. The text reads: 'One side says that LLMs lack knowledge of the world because they're extensively trained on text and have no model of the real world, the other side says LLMs have PhD-level intelligence. Guys, guys -- you're both right.' The joke cleverly implies that PhDs also lack real-world knowledge, being extensively trained on text (academic papers) with no practical model of the real world -- a sharp double burn on both LLMs and PhD holders
Use J and K for navigation
Comments
12Comment deleted
LLMs and PhDs: both extensively trained on text, both confidently hallucinate under pressure, and both will give you a beautifully articulated answer that falls apart the moment you try to apply it in production
An LLM is the ultimate junior developer: it can explain the theory of distributed systems perfectly but still doesn't know that pouring coffee on the server is a bad idea
LLMs are like that staff engineer who nails the architecture review but still forgets how elevators work after an all-nighter
It's like hiring a brilliant consultant who's read every book ever written but has never left their office - they can eloquently explain why your distributed system should theoretically work while having no idea why it's currently on fire
LLMs are Schrödinger's intelligence: simultaneously too dumb to understand the physical world and smart enough to pass your PhD qualifying exams - until you actually need them to debug production
LLMs: aced every text-based PhD comps, but flunk the lab quals without a vision model
LLMs are Schrödinger’s intern: until the integration test runs, they’re both PhD and freshman. Production collapses the waveform
Of course PhD people lack knowledge of real world Comment deleted
mostly true, for anything except very narrow field of knowledge they lack it. Comment deleted
Do you have a Phd? Comment deleted
No wonder so many doctors are garbage Comment deleted
Banger! Comment deleted